My group compared Google Gemini, xAI (Grok), and Deep Seek.

Our prompt: “you’re a kitchen designer, I want to remodel my kitchen which is 4 meters long, 3 meters wide, and 2.5 meters tall. On the south side there is a big arch which covers the whole wall. Right next to it on the east side there is a doorway to the outside and exactly opposite there is a door to a staircase. On the east side there are two windows. I want you to ask me questions about the design of the kitchen one-by-one and if you have enough information I want you to describe and then generate an image based on my answers”

This is an example of both the Persona Pattern (Page 6 of the White et al article) and Chain of Thought Prompting which we talked about in class.

This prompt would be most helpful to DIY enthusiasts and homeowners while planning renovations. AI-powered image generations allows this audience to visualize their desired outcome by experimenting with different designs without committing to expensive changes. This prompt can also serve as a starting point for consultations with professional designers. 

I used a chatbot called Grok, developed by xAI. I chose this LLM because I had never worked with it before, or even heard of it until it was mentioned in class today. 

xAI’s response: 

Great! I’m excited to help you design your kitchen remodel. With the dimensions you’ve provided (4m long, 3m wide, 2.5m tall) and the layout details, I’ve got a basic picture of the space. Now, let’s refine the design with some questions to ensure it fits your needs and style: 

1. Functionality: How do you use your kitchen? Are you an avid cook needing lots of counter space and storage, or do you prefer a minimalist setup for quick meals? Do you want a dining area or an island included?

Once you answer these, I can describe the design and, if you’d like, confirm whether you want me to generate an image of it. What do you think?

We found that the first responses amongst all three LLM’s were really similar! The first question each LLM asked us in response was about the functionality of the kitchen, and how we would use it. 

Unfortunately, I realized after class that xAI is run by Elon Musk, which led me to immediately deleting my account. Please don’t forget the importance of carefully researching the corporations and individuals who benefit from our use, to avoid making the same mistake I did!!